Finest Fish For Fish Ponds In Stardew Valley

Abstract

• Slimejack fish ponds yield useful Slime Eggs with a 2% probability every day, making them a dependable alternative.
• Spook fish ponds provide uncommon Treasure Chests with a 0.4% every day drop fee.
• Blue Discus ponds produce distinctive objects like Golden Coconuts.

There’s so much that gamers can do in Stardew Valley along with rising crops. Not solely can gamers develop their Fishing talent to reel within the bounties of the ocean and rivers, however they will even increase fish on their farms. To take action, gamers can buy Fish Ponds from Robin, the native carpenter. Every pond prices 5,000 gold and requires 200 Stones, 5 Seaweed, and 5 Inexperienced Algae to construct.

By inserting a fish in a pond, gamers can enable fish to breed, giving them a near-infinite provide of that individual species. Populated Fish Ponds also can produce Roe, in addition to different objects based mostly on the kind of fish they comprise. The wide range of further objects could make it difficult for gamers to find out the perfect fish for his or her ponds, as they could wish to know which species would be the most profitable. To simplify issues for all Stardew Valley farmers, these are the finest fish for Fish Ponds in Stardew Valley, based mostly on the objects they produce, how simple the fish are to acquire, and the way sensible it’s to develop a pond’s inhabitants.

Up to date April 2, 2025, by Mohsen Baquery: Stardew Valley 1.6 didn’t add any new fish species, but it surely did introduce some new objects just like the Golden Animal Crackers, Bait Maker, Fish Smoker, and Problem Bait that remodeled fishing. Fish ponds, then again, have just about remained the identical, although extra gamers need to make the most of them as passive revenue sources. To assist these profit-seeking followers, this listing has been revised to incorporate extra choices for a fish pond, together with further details about every candidate to assist gamers make up their minds.

Up to date September 10, 2025, by Demaris Oxman: With Stardew Valley coming to Ps Plus this month, many avid gamers are returning to this cozy farming sim, or maybe even selecting it up for the primary time. Those that discover themselves having fun with the sport’s fishing mechanics would possibly discover themselves constructing fish ponds to show their farm right into a hatchery of types, cultivating Aged Roe and Caviar. For gamers who wish to take advantage of out of fish ponds, this listing has been up to date with extra data on the sport’s finest fish, the place to catch them, and learn how to develop their populations.

Stonefish

Finest Merchandise: Diamond

The Stonefish is a comparatively uncommon creature that may be caught on Flooring 20 of the mines. When a Stonefish pond reaches most capability, it has an opportunity to provide a Diamond, probably the most useful gem stones within the recreation.

The opposite objects that the Stonefish produces (that are rather more frequent) are much less useful, although, and most are simple to seek out by way of mining. Nonetheless, for gamers devoted to cultivating various kinds of fish on their farms, it may be a good selection for individuals who have area for an additional pond.

Inhabitants Quests

Sea Cucumber

Finest Merchandise: Fortunate Lunch

• Replica: 2 Days
• Base Worth: 75g

Sea Cucumber won’t be the primary alternative that involves thoughts when contemplating the perfect fish for a pond in Stardew Valley. Nonetheless, this deep-sea creature comes with a aspect product that shouldn’t be ignored: the cooking recipe Fortunate Lunch. Utilizing one Sea Cucumber, a Tortilla, and a Blue Jazz, the participant can prepare dinner a satisfying meal able to boosting Luck by three factors. Gamers can catch this deep-sea creature within the Ocean earlier than 7pm throughout Fall or Winter, or within the Night time Market submarine.

For veteran gamers, Tremendous Cucumber can be a greater possibility. Though fairly uncommon to acquire, Tremendous Cucumber has a small probability of manufacturing Iridium Roe within the pond, which provides to its total worth. (The every day probability of getting an Iridium Roe from a Tremendous Cucumber pond is about 5%, which isn’t that unhealthy in contrast with different uncommon objects’ drop charges.) Catch the Tremendous Cucumber within the ocean after 6pm in any season besides Spring, or anytime in the course of the Night time Market.

Sea Cucumber Objects:

Tremendous Cucumber Objects:

Inhabitants Quests

As soon as a fish pond’s inhabitants reaches a sure quantity, the fish will request a particular merchandise to extend the pond’s most capability. Every fish varies with regard to when this quest happens, in addition to the objects they could ask for. If gamers are elevating Sea Cucumbers, they will anticipate the fish to ask for one of many following objects on the following milestones:

For Tremendous Cucumbers, these are the potential requests:

Stingray

Finest Merchandise: Dragon Tooth

• Replica: 4 Days
• Base Worth: 180g

Most gamers use Stingray fish ponds to reap Roe and Cinder Shards. Whereas each these things are fairly sensible to have on the farm, Stingrays also can produce Dragon Tooth, which is without doubt one of the rarest objects within the recreation. Day-after-day, a Stingray fish pond has as much as a 5% probability of dropping a Dragon Tooth, which the participant can use to craft distinctive objects like Warp Totem: Island and Mini-Forge, in addition to the Island Obelisk.

Stingrays usually are not essentially the perfect moneymaking fish. However for a veteran participant with sufficient area to carry a few spare ponds, they’re an economical, low-risk manner of acquiring some uncommon supplies with out having to depart the farm. Catch one within the Pirate Cove on Ginger Island.

Inhabitants Quests

Squid or Midnight Squid

Finest Merchandise: Squid Ink

• Replica: 3 Days
• Base Worth: 80g to 100g

Squids are an awesome addition to a fisherman’s pond resulting from their excessive drop charges of Squid Ink. Whereas Squid Ink isn’t price a lot when offered, it’s important for crafting Seafoam Pudding. This cooked dish boosts the Fishing talent by +3, making it good for farming legendary fish. With ten Squids within the pond, gamers have as much as a 69% probability to get Squid Ink per day.

Gamers can catch Squid after 6pm throughout Winter, or at any time of day throughout Squid Fest. The Midnight Squid can solely be caught within the Submarine on the Night time Market.

Inhabitants Quests

Squid:

The Midnight Squid’s first two inhabitants quests are the identical, however it is going to additionally request an Ocean Stone when the pond’s inhabitants reaches 8.

Slimejack

Finest Merchandise: Slime Eggs

• Replica: Each 3 Days
• Base Worth: 100g

Whereas the Slimejack might not be essentially the most profitable alternative for a fish pond, its means to drop Slime Eggs makes it a dependable possibility. Gamers can both hatch these eggs into Slimes utilizing a Slime Incubator or sell them immediately for 1,000 gold.

There may be as much as a 2% probability {that a} Slimejack pond with 9 to 10 fish will yield one Inexperienced Slime Egg per day. Gamers can catch this fish within the Mutant Bug Lair.

Inhabitants Quests

Lionfish

Finest Merchandise: Tiger Slime Egg

This tropical fish is one other nice alternative for gamers who benefit from the Slime Hutch, because it has a small probability to provide the uncommon Tiger Slime Egg. When hatched within the Slime Incubator, these eggs will produce a Tiger Slime, the striped orange slimes discovered solely on Ginger Island.

Lionfish ponds also can produce Taro Tubers, which gamers can develop into Taro Root. Like most fish, they will additionally produce Roe. Gamers can catch Lionfish in salt water on Ginger Island, within the Island West and South areas.

Inhabitants Quests

Spook Fish

Finest Merchandise: Treasure Chests

• Replica: Each 4 Days
• Base Worth: 220g

Spook Fish can solely be caught on the Submarine trip on the Night time Market. For gamers who wish to enhance their probabilities of getting Treasure Chests, inserting Spook Fish in a fish pond is the best choice.

Treasure Chests will be offered for a formidable 5,000 gold, providing a quick approach to increase your income. Nonetheless, acquiring these chests is uncommon, as every Spook fish pond has solely a 0.4% probability of dropping one per day. Extra generally, the pond yields Roe, which is considerably much less worthwhile than Treasure Chests.

Inhabitants Quests

Blue Discus

Finest Merchandise: Golden Coconut

• Replica: Each 3 Days
• Base Worth: 120g

The Blue Discus is a phenomenal tropical fish found on Ginger Island. It may be caught in freshwater our bodies on the Island’s North and West sides throughout any season. When positioned in a fish pond on the farm, the Blue Discus reproduces each three days. Moreover, they drop objects that may’t be present in Pelican City — issues like Bananas and golden Coconuts.

Like most fish, the likeliest merchandise a Blue Discus fish pond will yield is its unique Roe. Every day, there’s as much as a 76% probability that the participant will get this product. Nonetheless, there’s additionally a 4% probability that the pond will produce a Golden Coconut, which is a comparatively uncommon and useful merchandise. (Cracking Golden Coconuts can reward players with Golden Walnuts, Banana Saplings, Mango Saplings, Pineapple Seeds, Taro Tubers, Mahogany Seeds, Fossilized Skulls, Iridium Ores, and Golden Helmets.)

Inhabitants Quests

Ice Pip

Finest Merchandise: Diamond

• Replica: Each 5 Days
• Base Worth: 500g

Ice Pips are a uncommon fish species that thrive in freezing circumstances, that means they will solely be caught on Flooring 60 within the Frozen Earth section of the Mines. When positioned in a fish pond, Ice Pips reproduce each 5 days. They’re a useful fish, with a base promoting worth of 500g, which will be doubled to 1,000g for iridium high quality.

Fortunate players may also receive free Diamonds by protecting this fish. When the pond’s inhabitants reaches 9 or ten, there’s a 0.7% every day probability of getting one. Nonetheless, it is best to not depend on this merchandise, as it’s a comparatively uncommon drop.

Inhabitants Quests

Rainbow Trout

Finest Merchandise: Prismatic Shard

• Replica: Each 2 Days
• Base Worth: 56g

Discovered swimming in freshwater our bodies across the Valley, the Rainbow Trout is without doubt one of the finest fish to position in ponds on the farm in Stardew Valley. They are often caught within the River flowing by way of Pelican City and Cindersap Forest and the Mountain Lake on sunny summer time days. Rainbow Trout reproduce rapidly (about each two days) when positioned in a fish pond.

Probably the most useful merchandise a Rainbow Trout pond can produce is the Prismatic Shard. Nonetheless, like different uncommon drops, it’s fairly unlikely for the typical participant to acquire one. The possibility of receiving a Prismatic Shard from this pond is simply 0.09% per day, which interprets to roughly a ten% probability per 12 months.

Inhabitants Quests